What color does my pink stucco house want to be?

Guest post by Dawn Bininger

In March of this year I fell helplessly in love. Head over heels, knee-buckling, palm-sweaty LOVE. With a house. My house. My FIRST house.

Hi. My name is Dawn and I am obsessed with my 1959 Ranch house. Obsessed in a good way. Not the creepy Craigslist stalker kind of way.

It has been a life-long dream of mine to own a REAL house. I had spent my entire life in apartments, trailers, and condos. No. There is NO harm in that, but for me, a house signified something; as a child raised by a single mom, I assumed if you owned a house, you had money. It mattered not to my child’s brain that the house might be really small, or in disrepair. I only knew it was NOT an apartment.

I had to own a house someday. It took me 38 years to achieve that goal.

Anyway, I could bore you all with the love story of me and my house. How we met. How she told me she was mine. But you would most certainly turn and run.

So let me get down to business. My house is PINK. Pink stucco. Its been pink since the day it was built. And no, it’s not a fabulous HOT pink, or a sweet, pale pink, its actually a fairly nasty coral-looking pink. It’s dirty. And I don’t think its EVER been repainted. I don’t live in Florida where a pink stucco house is acceptable and common. I live in Central Ohio, where pink houses are a bit harder to come by.

It needs to be repainted desperately, and it’s one of the next major renovations I am going to do in the spring.

My fiance and I promised ourselves that we would do our very best to keep the architectural integrity of our house while updating her to this century. To that point we have kept a lot, and ripped out little. I guess I was thinking MOSTLY of her interior. I didn’t think much about the outside.

When I first saw the house I knew I would paint it anything OTHER than pink. I assumed my neighbors would be thrilled. It is the only pink house in the neighborhood, and one of the few remaining stucco ones. Most of them have been sided. I even got two estimates! I was so gung-ho on doing this!

I was thinking a nice sage green, OR a nice deep gray blue. It has stone all around it, which I have NO INTENTION of removing, I had to pull colors out of that stone. I also have white accents. So I was heavily leaning towards the gray blue.

Until I started really thinking about the house. And how long it’s been pink. And maybe I should paint it a newer, hipper pink? Would she be sad if she was no longer pink? Would me changing her color somehow tilt the universe a little bit? So I started being wishy washy about painting her again, especially after I read Offbeat Home’s post about houses of unusual colors. I thought how much my neighbors would probably hate it if the house remained pink. I thought about the brownstone that had been painted pink. And although I loved it, it looked so out of place. It was not meant to be pink. My house was built to be pink.

I’m so confused! What do I do? I don’t mind living in a pink house. Not really. I am a bit kooky that way anyway. But, is it logical to repaint her in a nicer shade of pink? Or is okay to paint her a new, more modern color? Am I tempting the architectural Gods by changing her color after 50 years?

Decisions. Decisions.

Comments on What color does my pink stucco house want to be?

  1. I have to admit that, a few paragraphs in I was definitely thinking “Paint it a better shade of pink!”

    Your house has such an overwhelming roof overhang, I think you need a really strong, bright color. If not pink, I would go with, like, a really bright green.

  2. I agree on the brightness- the amount to be painted is visually not that much, so it would be nice to have some fun. I don’t know that it has to be pink, but a bright raspberry could be delightful.

  3. I’d say a different shade of pink. She really is such a beautiful house and it wears the colour so well. You fell for the house when it was pink so maybe that’s a sign. Nothing wrong with giving her an update though. Maybe she’d like to wear a different shade for a while…

  4. The best thing about paint- you can change it. I know it is pricey to do, but go with your gut. This is your unique love story and you should be thrilled every time you go home. Don’t worry about the opinion of your neighbors, I know that your house has withstood some of the pink criticism before. Good luck, and be happy!

  5. I think raspberry would look great. But am with you on the blue/grey idea. Maybe deep sea green (turquoise)?

    As for the pink, I would not be too concerned about it. Paint it in a colour you would like. I think painting it in a other shade of pink would be just as being out of tune with its architectural style as painting it in any other colour. Except for the mustard-gold maybe. So paint it in a colour YOU like.

  6. I lived around stucco all of my life in Vegas. Stucco is hard and awkward on bright colors. There is something about stucco, where purple that would look great on wood siding ends up looking like a bad fast food drive through on stucco. Having said that, if you went with a soft yellow, then painted the swirly columns black, you’d get a nice grey/yellow/black thing going. Like a happy bee! Also, those bushes are dying to be trimmed into awesome animals!!!!

    • The tall bushes have already been ripped out. LOL. We did that the first month we were here. We HATED how they blocked in the front door, you can see in the second picture they are gone. THEY WERE A BEAR TO REMOVE!!! The smaller ones are staying until I can get a landscaper in here to give me some new ideas.

  7. I also think you should stick with pink! A more modern pink, but pink nonetheless. We were in the maritimes this fall and there are so many houses painted pink there it was great! Plus pink is making a comeback… have u ever read retrorenovation.com? There are lots of posts and forums about colour choices etc for mid mod homes. I vote to keep your house in all it’s pink glory. Embrace the maritime spirit. Bring some colour to Ohio! It needs it 🙂

  8. I LOVE the suggestion of repainting your house a lovely sweet raspberry color (something like this maybe? http://www.utrechtart.com/dsp_view_product.cfm?item=27189)! I, too, hail from Central Ohio and honestly, there aren’t enough interestingly colored houses around here!

    One thing you might want to check on is seeing if your neighborhood has any restrictions regarding house paint colors. When I was growing up in a suburb of Columbus, one gentleman painted his house neon green to spite his neighbors (after complaints that his grass wasn’t green/well-taken-care-of enough) and there was a big kerfuffle in the neighborhood afterwards. However, they had nothing in their neighborhood association agreement against it and to this day, like 10 years later, it is still neon green. If you have a neighborhood association, it’s worth checking out the bylaws 🙂

  9. Paint it poodle-skirt pink. Neck scarf pink. 1950’s nostalgia pink. That house is so 50’s I’m surprised that’s not the pink it was in the first place.
    Or, if you want to go with something that will still pull grey out of the rock, do a ’57 Chevy blue/teal still 50’s and bright, but a little cooler on the eyes around grey and white (http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-3QYkrp1hmKs/TdGKKZD25rI/AAAAAAAAA10/mcHgcf-xl7U/s1600/57ChevyBelAir.jpg).

  10. If you paint it another color, don’t go for a drab gray-blue. Go for a bright blue, a bright green, or a lovely lavender! I also like the idea of a raspberry color (keeps some tones of pink). You don’t get to see much of the stucco visually, so you might as well make it pop!

  11. I’m a fan of bright colors, but I think the fading of the paint would be important, especially if you’re not surrounded by shade that would protect it from the sun.
    Don’t do lemon yellow- there’s one house in our neighborhood that is that color and it looks weirdly alien in a brick house neighborhood. Unless that’s your thing.

  12. Thank you everyone for the suggestions. What you cant see here is the back of the house which is ALL stucco. NO STONE, and two stories. So Raspberry is PROBABLY not a great option. It would be a lot of raspberry from behind. I am really leaning away from the gray blue now though, even though the stones have a ton of gray and blue in them…I am now wondering if a nice mint green might work???? There is a lot of greenery in the yard and there are three pine trees right in the front yard. But, I still kind of have a soft spot for the pink….

    • We just painted our house and originally thought we were going to do mint green. Once we slapped a sample of the paint on the house though we realized it looked weird and was going to take at least three coats to cover up the awful poop brown the original color was. We ended up going with a deep green instead. It’s funny because the green looks out of place in our neighborhood, a sea of beige and grey, but everyone is so thrilled with the green. I think really they’re just happy it’s no longer poop brown.

      • LOL. Yes, there are a LOT of poop brown and beige homes here too. Its like everyone either sided their stucco or painted it beige and poop brown. There is one other light colored stucco about two blocks away and its a peach color…

        • Yeah just paint some swatches and see where it takes you. Maybe even choose one or two colors you wouldn’t remotely consider usually. Paint samples are only $3 at Lowes so you won’t break the bank going sample crazy 🙂

    • I would try to get paint samples, and then put little splotches of it on each side of the house. See how the sun hits it, the way it looks in shadows, etc. Do it with a few colors you are thinking of, and then decide which you like best. Having random paint splotches on your house for a week is better than having a gross color on there for a lifetime.

  13. It’s such a fun house I wouldn’t paint it a muted colour, being a ’50s house you should stay with something bright. Like maybe a bright butter yellow or a bright blue or green, but in all of this deciding, stick with what makes you both happy. If you don’t like pink change it, if you can handle the pink stick with it, but update the paint so that it’s not so faded.

    • I have thought about this. I really want to do something with the front door. My heart is set on red right now. The door is in really bad shape and has been painted numerous times. Its also NOT a solid door!!! (What were they thinking??) But I LOVE the windows so I think I will paint it and then put a see through storm door in front to make it more weather proof. I cant do a red door though if I leave the house pink…LOL

      • Oooh! But you could do mint green or robin’s egg blue with a red door. Awesome colour combos that are also very reminiscent of the 1950’s.

        • Oh my god. Robin’s egg blue house with a red door!? YOU JUST MADE ME LUST FOR A HOUSE NOT MADE OF CRAPPY WOOD. <3

          That would be
          the most amazing house

          • No reason you can’t do that with a wooden house. I’ve been many Craftsman bungalows that have been renovated and are painted bright blue with a red door. Almost bought one myself but it was out of my budget 🙁

  14. Having gone through a phase where I almost became a hoarder I recently had to re-evaluate my sentimentality. It’s a funny thing that, making us hang on to stuff that we may not even like, you don’t need to let it dictate your house colour. It’s your house now, and time to make your mark on it. Personally I think Sage Green sounds awesome, and don’t forget, if you feel too guilty in the end, you can always go back to pink!

    • This is true…I can always change it. Although, I would hate to lose several thousand dollars. I think the paint sample idea is fabulous and maybe I can try three or four colors and let them sit for a few weeks to see which one grows on me???

  15. i would stick with the gray-blue. maybe i am more classic, but outside renovations seems to be pricey and i wouldn’t want to regret spending hundreds or thousands of dollars on something i would end up hating. painting the inside room is less risky and costly… just my opinion!

    • Neat!
      What about a pale red that you could do the red door with?
      Or a robin’s egg blue would be fun and bright, and blue complements red.
      The house I live in is peach stucco with a red door and looks pretty great. ;p

  16. Why not repaint the house in the same shade of pink? Especially if you think it is the original color, I think it is awesome to be a steward of such a fun, and architecturally distinctive house!

  17. So I’m sort of feeling like none of us can or should tell you what to paint your house, because ultimately it is yours, and its your neighborhood, and your life, and we can’t really make aesthetic judgments on that. Well, I don’t feel comfortable doing that, anyway.

    Print out your doctored pictures. Put them up on your walls. Look at them. Move them around. Sit with them. Show them to people. (But not necessarily for advice.) Find which ones draw you and which ones don’t. Get rid of those ones. Really search out how you and your partner feel, and what you think would be best for your own collective tastes.

    I hope you can find a color that is totally right for you!

    • Well, we aren’t looking for anyone to REALLY decide for us. It was phrased like that more as a general “Which way do we go?” kind of thing. We are pretty offbeat ourselves and typically do our own thing…However, I did want to throw it out there to see what other offbeat people thought. I like to gather as much info as I can then I just make a decision based on my gut at that time. Hah. Which changes frequently!

Read more comments

Join the Conversation